
Peace Dove Carrying an Olive Branch
NJ Student Learning Standards for Social Studies (2020):
- 6.1.8.CivicsPI.3.b: Evaluate the effectiveness of the fundamental principles of the Constitution (i.e., consent of the governed, rule of law, federalism, limited government, separation of powers, checks and balances and individual rights) in establishing a federal government that allows for growth and chance over time.
- 6.3.8.CivicsPI.1: Evaluate, take and defend a position on why government is necessary and the purposes government should serve.
- 6.3.8.CivicsPI.4: Investigate the roles of political, civil, and economic organizations in shaping people’s lives and share this information with individuals who might benefit from this information.
Objectives: Students will be able to:
- Explain what domestic tranquility meant to the Founder and today
- Identify ways to measure and compare domestic tranquility
- Analyze and draw conclusions about how well the United States has met the goal of insuring domestic tranquility, supporting their conclusions with evidence
- Brainstorm ideas for promoting domestic tranquility
Background: What is “domestic tranquility”?
When the Constitution was drafted in 1787, there was great discord between the thirteen states. For six years under the Articles of Confederation, each state viewed its own sovereignty and power as paramount. States argued over trade and tariff policy, boundaries and western lands, and navigation rights on rivers. In addition, most every state had its own militia and currency.
In addition, there was great unrest within states. In 1786 and early 1787, a series of violent protests erupted in several states over unfair tax policies, cash shortages, inflation, debt and land foreclosures. The most notable was in Massachusetts where a rural population of impoverished farmers violently resisted policies of the merchant class. Led by Revolutionary war veteran Daniel Shays, over 4,000 armed rebels closed the courts and attacked a federal arsenal at Springfield. (For more background, see Shays’ Rebellion - Definition, Date & Significance | HISTORY)
In 1787, the Framers of the U.S. Constitution were alarmed by state disputes and civil unrest as well as the inability of the national government to address the conflicts within our borders. The Framers wanted to empower the new federal government with the authority and power to stop such domestic conflicts in the future. Consequently the Preamble to the United States Constitution proclaimed the goal to “ensure domestic tranquility” which they understood broadly as “peace and quiet at home.” The condition of domestic tranquility was essential, they thought to productive pursuit of liberty and property.
Today, we live in a much informed, integrated and international world. Consequently the meaning of “domestic tranquility” has shifted. Today domestic tranquility requires laws which protect the right to protest, peaceful assemblies and free expression without violence. However, domestic tranquility also requires protection against terrorism and other foreign threats and protection of national security. (For more information see Freedom of Expression and How Does the Constitution Provide for Domestic Tranquility? American Fundamentals, Part 18
Brainstorming Activity: How can we measure and ensure “domestic tranquility”?
Ask students to work together in small groups to brainstorm how to measure “domestic tranquility”. Have each group share their responses in turn and make a class list. Then engage the full class in a discussion about their responses. The class list may include which might/should include (but should not be limited to):
- The presence of absence of civil war
- The presence or absence of violent civil unrest
- The ability of citizens to express discontent and dissent
- Peaceful transfers of political power without political coups (i.e., sudden, illegal, and usually violent, seizure of power from a government)
- Trust or distrust in government
- Levels of criminal activity
- Economic indicators such as income disparity and poverty levels
- Respect and tolerance for social and political difference
- Other ideas?
When the class list is complete, have students reconvene in their small groups and brainstorm conditions that must be present in society to ensure domestic tranquility. Follow with a full class in a discussion about their responses. The class list may include:
- Just and equal laws
- Police and national guard to enforce the laws and preserve the peace
- Accountability in law enforcement
- Accountability in political leadership
- Protection for public participation in governance (ex. Free and fair election)
- Protection and respect for First Amendment rights like free expression, peaceful assemblies and petitioning government for redress of grievance
- Presence of a free press
- Independence of the judiciary
- Respect for majority rule combined with protection for minority rights
- Others?
Research and Critical Thinking Activity: How well has the United States ensured domestic tranquility?
Using the criteria established from the class discussion regarding how to measure and ensure “domestic tranquility,” have students individually consider how well the United States has ensured domestic tranquility. Students should be encouraged to research and compare the domestic tranquility of the United States with that of other countries. It is okay for students to use basic information from Wikipedia for this purpose. The activity might be done in the format of a class discussion or as individual student essays (which might be used as an assessment). Responses may include (though not necessarily be limited to):
Civil Wars:
- Many countries around the globe have experienced years of civil wars, including (for example) Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Mexico, Somalia, Libya, and Myanmar.
- In the almost 250 years of its existence, the United States has had one civil war. ∙
Peaceful transfer of political power versus political coups:
- Wikipedia includes a long list of coups and attempted coups around the world at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_coups_and_coup_attempts. The list is extensive, including several in Athens and Rome in BC; in Europe (France, Sweden, Netherlands, Denmark, Spain) during the 1700 and 1800s; dozens in South America in the 1800s (Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Costa Rica, Mexico); continuing around the globe through the 1900s until today (including Russia, China, Japan, Thailand, Turkey, Iraq, Ethiopia, Egypt, Algeria, Albania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland, Lithuania, Latvia, Germany, Bolivia, Venezuela, and Cuba, among others).
- By comparison, the only event that came close to the definition of a coup was the violent effort on January 6, 2021 to prevent certification of the electoral college results in the presidential election of 2020.
Trust in government:
- The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) is an international organization that works to shape policies that foster prosperity, equality, opportunity and well-being. It periodically conducts a survey of trust in government in its member countries. The OECD defines “trust in government” as the share (percentage) of people who report having confidence in their national government. In the 2020 survey, those surveyed in Switzerland indicated the highest level of trust in their government at 84.6%; Those surveyed in Chile indicated the lowest trust in their government at 17.1%. (For more, see Trust in government | OECD)
- By comparison, trust in government by those surveyed in the United States was at 46.7%. This means that more than half of the population does not trust their state or national government.
Crime:
- Crime in the United States has been recorded since the early 1600s. Crime rates have varied over time, with a sharp rise after 1900 and reaching a peak between the 1970s and early 1990s. After 1994, crime rates began to fall. However, violent crime increased significantly again in 2020. Overall, the total crime rate of the United States is higher than developed countries, in Europe and East Asia, but lower than many South American countries and Russia.
- Overall crime statistic comparisons are difficult to conduct, as the definition and categorization of crimes varies across countries. However, the definition of “homicide” is fairly consistent. The homicide rate in the United States is substantially higher: than other G-7 countries: 5 per 100,000 population, as opposed to 1.1 in England, 1.2 in Australia and .8 in Germany. (See Crime Rate by Country 2026
Violence in the streets (peaceful protests excluded):
- The United States has had its share of violent or destructive protests, starting during colonial times and continuing through the 1900s (e.g., Boston Tea Party in 1773; New York City draft riots in 1863, Haymarket riot in Chicago in 1886, Chicago Race Riot in 1919, Tulsa Race Massacre 1921, Zoot Suite riot in 1943, riots in Newark and Detroit in 1967 and the LA Riots in 1995) (For more, see 6 Violent Uprisings in the United States | HISTORY
- Most protests, however, have been peacefully held by those marching or boycotting (e.g., Women's Suffrage Parade, 1913; Montgomery Bus Boycott, 1956; California Grapes, 1960s; The March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom, 1963; I have a Dream Rally, 1963; Stonewall Riots, 1969). (For more see Historic Protest Movements in Every Decade | HISTORY)
- A protest may turn into a riot when it involves the destruction of property, the use of weapons, or when it results in people becoming injured. Then it becomes necessary for law enforcement to intervene.
Poverty:
- Some studies by sociologists, criminologists and economists have concluded that poverty and increasing income inequality is connected to crime levels. (For more, see Connections Among Poverty, Incarceration, and Inequality)
- While the U.S. is not in the group of nations with the highest income inequality (such as South Africa, Zambia, Brazil and Mozambique), it is also not in the group of nations with the lowest income inequality (such as the Czech Republic, Belgium, Iceland and Finland). It is in the middle, along with Ivory Coast, Peru, and Bulgaria) (For more see Income Inequality by Country 2026)
- Unfortunately, income inequality in the United States is growing and is higher than in most other advanced economies. (For more see Trends in U.S. income and wealth inequality | Pew Research Center)
Have students individually or the class as a whole draw conclusions about how well the United States has met its goal of ensuring domestic tranquility, supporting their conclusions with evidence.
Extension Activity: How can “We the People” encourage greater domestic tranquility?
The Constitution of the United States begins with the words “We the People.” That implies that it is, in part, our responsibility to “ensure domestic tranquility.” Ask students: “How can We the People encourage greater domestic tranquility in the United States today?”

Preamble to the Constitution of the United States
In small groups of 3-5, they should create an action plan for citizens to restore domestic tranquility to a politically and culturally divided nation. Their action plan should include:
- A clear definition of “domestic tranquility”
- Consideration of the causes and effect of disruption to domestic tranquility
- Non-governmental organizations that would be involved
- Governmental entities and policy makers that would be contacted
- Constitutional rights and powers that would be utilized
- Specific steps of progressive action
- Reflection of the positive effects that would result from the restoration of domestic tranquility.
Student groups should present their action plan to the class in a digital portfolio.