Photograph of bas relief by Arthur Rothstein at Boca Raton Museum of Art

Photograph of bas-relief by Arthur Rothstein at Boca Raton Museum of Art

Prepared by: The New Jersey Center for Civic Education, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ

Grade Level: 6-8

Standards:

  • 3.8.CivicsPR.1: Analyze primary sources to explain how democratic ideas in the United States developed from the historical experiences of ancient societies, England, and the North American colonies.
  • 3.8.CivicsPR.2: Evaluate the effectiveness of the fundamental principles of the Constitution (i.e., consent of the governed, rule of law, federalism, limited government, separation of powers, checks and balances, and individual rights) in establishing a federal government that allows for growth and change over time.
  • 3.8.CivicsPR.3: Take a position on an issue in which fundamental ideals and principles are in conflict (e.g., liberty, equality).
  • 3.8.CivicsPR.7: Compare how ideas become laws at the local, state, and national level.
  • 3.8.CivicsPR.5: Engage in simulated democratic processes (e.g., legislative hearings, judicial proceedings, elections) to understand how conflicting points of view are addressed in a democratic society.

Objectives: Students will be able to:

  • Explain what “promote the general welfare” means
  • Give examples of governmental actions that promote the general welfare
  • Evaluate the debate over the General Welfare clause at the Constitutional Convention.
  • Identify and discuss issues debated today that involve interpretation of the General Welfare clause.
  • Participate in a simulated congressional hearing on funding for the National Endowment for the Arts.

To Promote the General Welfare - Background Information

The Preamble to the United States Constitution lists as one of the purposes for creating our government: “…to promote the General Welfare”. Article I of the U.S. Constitution, which lays out the powers of the national government, reiterates this language in greater specificity: “to lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defense and “General welfare.” What is the “General welfare”?

In listing the purposes for establishing the government of the United States of America, the Constitution makes clear that a main purpose is to make decisions for the common good—to improve our society for the benefit of all of its members. The general welfare, also sometimes referred to as the “public welfare” or the “public good” or the “common good”, is the concern of the government for the health, peace, and safety of its citizens.

How has “promote the general welfare” been defined historically?

General national welfare pertains to purposes and policies states could not achieve on their own due to lack of coordination among the states. For example, centralizing power over tariffs in the national government eliminated the states' lack of coordination over ports under the Articles of Confederation, allowing the national government to raise revenue from tariffs on imports.

Historically, promoting the general welfare has meant improving transportation, promoting agriculture and industry, protecting health and the environment, and seeking ways to solve social and economic problems.

The idea that the government should work for the “general welfare,” or the benefit of all, has been repeatedly stated. In 1914, before he became the 23rd president, Calvin Coolidge explained this idea concretely to the Massachusetts Senate: “We are all members of one body. The welfare of the weakest and the welfare of the most powerful are inseparably bound together. Industry cannot flourish if labor languishes. Transportation cannot prosper if manufactures decline. The general welfare cannot be provided for in any one act, but it is well to remember that the benefit of one is the benefit of all, and the neglect of one is the neglect of all.”

More recently, Harvard historian Jill Lepore described the connection between providing for the general welfare and taxes: “Taxes are what we pay for civilized society, for modernity, and for prosperity. The wealthy pay more because they have benefitted more. Taxes, well laid and well spent, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, and promote the general welfare. Taxes protect property and the environment; taxes make business possible. Taxes pay for roads, schools, bridges, police, and teachers. Taxes pay for doctors, nursing homes, and medicine. During an emergency, such as an earthquake or a hurricane, taxes fund rescue workers, shelters, and services. For people whose lives are devastated by other kinds of disaster, like the disaster of poverty, taxes pay, even, for food.”

The Center for Civic Education video link, The Meaning of the “General Welfare” in the Constitution provides additional information for students.

The Meaning of “General Welfare” in the Constitution: American Fundamentals, Part 22

Activity #1 - Checking for understanding: Have students give examples of actions that the government might take to promote the common good.  Write them on the board.

Activity #2 - Simulated Congressional Hearing activity: Have students use their understanding of the general welfare by engaging in a simulated Congressional hearing about funding for the National Endowment for the Arts.

National Endowment for the Arts

Divide your class into three groups:

  • Members of the Senate Appropriations Committee, which is considering funding for the National Endowment for the Arts
  • Members of the National Endowment for the Arts, an independent federal agency which funds, promotes, and strengthens the creative capacity of diverse communities nationwide
  • Members of a group opposed to some of the art that has been exhibited at venues funded by the National Endowment for the Arts and believes that using tax money for art projects is not something that promotes the general welfare.

Have the students, playing the role of staff at the National Endowment for the Arts, argue that funding diverse arts programs across the country promotes the general welfare.

Have the group opposed to funding the National Endowment for the Arts argue why funding diverse arts programs and projects does not promote the general welfare.

Have the members of the Senate Appropriations Committee listen to the arguments, publicly deliberate, and decide whether the National Endowment for the Arts promotes the general welfare and should be funded, supporting their conclusions with reasoning.

Activity #3 - Founding Debates - The General Welfare Clause

the Founders holding the Constitution and Article I document

Image of the Founders holding the Constitution and an image of Article I of the Constitution

The General Welfare Clause in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution—authorizing Congress to tax and spend “to provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States”—sparked sharp disagreement among the Founders over its scope. James Madison and Thomas Jefferson insisted it conferred no independent power but merely described the purpose of taxing and spending in support of the other enumerated powers, warning that a broader reading would erase constitutional limits on federal authority. Alexander Hamilton countered that the clause granted Congress a distinct power to tax and spend for any national purpose promoting the general welfare, a view he advanced in his 1791 Report on Manufactures. This clash between strict and broad constructions persisted into the early republic, shaping debates over internal improvements, the national bank, and the proper bounds of federal power.

It is important for students to understand how the interpretation of the General Welfare Clause has shaped debates over the size and influence of the federal government.   For this activity, students should watch the Center for Civic Education’s video The Debate Over the General Welfare Clause, then break into pairs.  One student will take the side of James Madison, while the other will take the side of Alexander Hamilton.  Student pairs will have 2-3 minutes to engage in a point/counterpoint conversation.

The Debate Over the General Welfare Clause: American Fundamentals, Part 23

Activity #4 - What does General Welfare mean today?

Today, just as the Founders disagreed over whether the General Welfare Clause gave Congress broad power to spend for any national purpose or only for those tied to its enumerated powers, we still debate what “general welfare” means in practice. Consider a modern proposal, such as eliminating college tuition for all students at public universities, funded through federal taxes. In this activity, evaluate whether such a policy falls under the constitutional meaning of providing for the general welfare: Does it promote the common good of the nation as a whole, or does it stretch federal power beyond what the Founders intended? Discuss the arguments on both sides, weighing benefits, costs, and constitutional limits, and decide how you would interpret the clause if you were advising Congress today.  Other proposals may also be added, such as funding for school breakfast/lunch, school choice, subsidies for first-time homebuyers, and assistance with fertility treatments.

Final Activity – How well have we promoted the General Welfare?

reflecting the old English proverb many hands make light work

An image reflecting the old English proverb “many hands make light work”

The Preamble to the U.S. Constitution lists six big goals for our country, and one of them is to “promote the general welfare.” But what does that actually mean — and how well have we lived up to it? In this activity, you'll dig into that question by looking at real examples from American history and today, from public schools and parks to healthcare and clean water. You'll decide: What counts as “the general welfare”? Who gets to decide what people need? And has the United States done a good job of taking care of everyone, or are there still gaps?

Opening: To begin, read the Preamble aloud as a class. Ask students to underline or highlight the phrase “promote the general welfare.” As a group, brainstorm: What do you think “welfare” means here? (Note: this is not the same as the narrower, modern use of “welfare” to mean cash assistance — here it means the wellbeing of the whole community.)

Warm-up activity: The next step is to have students individually list 3–5 things they think people need to live safe, healthy lives (examples: clean water, safety, education, healthcare, a place to live). Share out a few responses as a class to build a working definition of “general welfare.”

Group research: Divide students into small groups. Assign each group 1–2 examples from the Evidence Examples table below (or let groups choose).  Students may also identify other examples for the activity.  For each example, groups should discuss and record their responses to the following prompts:

  1. What problem was this trying to solve?
  2. Does this count as promoting the “general welfare”? Why or why not?
  3. Rate how well it worked: Great / Okay / Not well — and explain your reasoning.
  4. Who might say this example does NOT show the government promoting the general welfare well? Why?

Class presentations: Provide sufficient time for groups to research and discuss the selected examples.  Each group shares their example and rating. Use the discussion questions below to guide a whole-class conversation.

Exit ticket: Students respond individually in writing to the prompt: “Overall, has the United States done a good job promoting the general welfare? Use at least three pieces of evidence from today's activity to support your answer.”

Evidence Examples Table

Use these examples during the small group investigation. Feel free to add local or more current examples relevant to your students.

Evidence Examples Table

Bonus Activity: Socratic Discussion

Socratic discussions are effective for building deep understanding of complex issues and developing dispositions necessary to support diversity of thought and civil discourse.  Interpretations and assessments of “promoting the general welfare” can be meaningfully evaluated through this approach. 

Opening: Explain to students the purpose of a Socratic discussion and emphasize the importance of civil discourse in the activity. 

Setting up: Have students move their desks into one large circle and distribute a copy of the five prompts to each student.  Give students 10 minutes to look over the prompts and write a few notes/points to make during the discussion.

Guiding the Discussion:  Announce to students that each prompt will have 7 – 10 minutes on the table for discussion (depending on the length of the class period).  The teacher should help guide the discussion but emphasize that students should encourage one another to participate. 

Socratic Prompts – “Promoting the General Welfare”

  • Is “general welfare” the same thing for every person, or does it look different depending on where you live or what you need?
  • Should the government be responsible for things like healthcare and internet access, or should that be left to individuals and private companies? Why?
  • Can you think of a time the government tried to promote the general welfare but it didn't work well, or helped some people more than others?
  • How do we decide when something is a “right” that the government should guarantee, versus something people should provide for themselves?
  • Are there needs today that you think the government isn't addressing well? What might a solution look like?

Exit ticket: Have students write a reflection on the discussion and explain how it impacted their understanding of “promoting the general welfare”